The River Tay is a tantalisingly beautiful Scottish river as you can clearly see here. This shot shows the lovely overhanging oak tree and the perfect cut riverbanks directly outside the Kinnaird fishing hut which is positioned slightly downstream of the Logierait Bridge. I took this perfect river shot while working on Kinnaird as a salmon fishing guide and tactical salmon fishing tuition provider.

This zoomed in shot was taken by me from the Rock Pool on Upper Kinnaird looking downstream to a party of 2 fishers accompanied by their professional salmon guide the moment a perfect 12lbs Spring salmon was landed which is barely visible in the landing net in this shot. The River Tay is a great Scottish salmon river even in low bright water conditions and this guest went on to land another salmon of similar size moments after this fine river shot was captured.

A Scottish Spring salmon is the most perfect creature of all and their physical beauty is something truly splendid especially when you have the tactical fishing awareness to create an up close inspection like this. This fine Springer I caught on the fly rod during April near Dunkeld on the River Tay in Perthshire. Look at the perfect marine colours this fish is still wearing while lying on this sand bar immediately before its quick release.

Look at this fine picture of the River Tay taken from the Upper Kinnaird salmon fishing hut which sits in a perfect elevated position overlooking the river. The little riffle you see in the picture is known as Daffodil Lie which often produces a quick salmon fishing guests.

This fine Summer salmon was landed by myself at the Tummel Tay confluence at sun up during the month of July. You can see this salmon is still in the landing net when I took this shot before I quickly released it back to the River Tay. The early morning sunlight caught this salmon's flanks perfectly.

This perfect 20lbs salmon was caught at the Kindallachan Pool neck on the Lower Kinnaird salmon beat during June while working as a salmon guide. I had my lucky Tweed jacket on that day which has been a magnet for salmon for decades on the Tay. Perfect salmon encounters like this stay in your memory banks for life even though a more accurate account of the capture lives on Youtube! My Tweed jacket and my Ocean chest waders are never too far away when I'm near a salmon river.

Salmon Fishing Catches

By Jock Monteith 21st October 2019

The biggest injustice I've seen in Scottish salmon fishing to date which supersedes the damage done to the ecology of Northern Hemisphere rivers via expanding populations is without doubt the introduction of 'catch statistics' as the main marketing driver for Scottish salmon fishing.

Assessing A Salmon Beat Correctly

How can you accurately assess a salmon beat's fishing potential where one beat lacks a regular returning client base to fish its pools each day which another beat may benefit from. Many salmon beats also have zero effective internet marketing presence which again attracts less anglers to the venue. Catch statistic marketing is seriously flawed and something as beautiful as a Scottish salmon beat should only have ever been marketed with good visual salmon fishing graphics and informative salmon fishing scripts that focus on the potential of the salmon beat's pool formations.

The Theme Of Salmon Catch Statistics

In the 70's when I first started fishing the River Tay salmon fishing was not driven by catch statistic marketing. It was the excitement and anticipation of going to the salmon river which was the main driver for all fishermen. The beat ghillie would talk about what had been caught recently or what the total for the previous season had been (only if asked). If a salmon beat is only marketed on current catches then it's created a marketing trap for itself in periods of lower stock levels or when less anglers are present to cover its pools consistently. The financial loss to a salmon beat created by the inevitable poor 'catch statistics' during low rod pressure periods represents a loss of revenue for that individual salmon beat and its local economy.

This perfect River Tay Springer was caught by myself on the 23rd of February from the Kinnaird salmon beat near Pitlochry. These early run Scottish salmon are perfect specimens and are guaranteed to get your heart racing. This fish was quickly returned and swam off strongly to continue its upstream migration to the upper reaches of the Tay. You can see the gold ABU Toby lure, Bruce & Walker Hexagraph spinning rod and Van Staal spinning reel used in the capture of this fine Spring run salmon.

Flawed Salmon Fishing Marketing

For a catch statistics based marketing approach to ever be remotely accurate you'd logically need to apply the exact same daily rod pressure to all salmon beats to gain the accurate picture as to the current fishing potential. As an example of that a beat can record 2 salmon that 6 anglers have fished for and still look better on paper than another beat which has caught 1 salmon for 1 angler fishing. The actual daily or weekly rod pressure is never taken into consideration to back up catch statistics therefor if you're looking purely to catch statistics for guidance you're not necessarily getting a true picture when it comes to assessing the potential of a salmon beat.

Here's a bunch of daffodils that mark one of the main salmon lies at the Green Bank Pool of the Kinnaird Beat near Dunkeld. The old school professional ghillies of Scotland were astute enough to realise that their Spring salmon showed up each year as the daffodils were flowering so perfect for riverbank Spring salmon lie identification purposes.

Why Is A Rested Salmon Pool Better

From a salmon fishing point of view a rested salmon pool will always stand you the most potent chance of a cooperating salmon as the less a salmon sees of a fly or lure the more likely it is to respond. If you're fishing on salmon pools that have been completely bombarded morning, noon & night then salmon will switch off completely more often than not. To my mind this is not true salmon fishing as there has to be an element in the fishing day where you know you're approaching a salmon pool that hasn't been over-fished.

Salmon Catch Statistic Marketing

Personally if I was the chairman of any Scottish salmon fishery board I'd instantly ban catch statistic internet marketing as all it has done is train homegrown salmon fishers to react primarily to the catch peaks which don't highlight actual rod pressure or other relative factors like how competent are the visiting salmon fishing guests. A fishery board chairman should be encouraging or demanding high quality graphic visuals from salmon beats for marketing purposes and encouraging beat ghillies to become more involved in sharing video footage & salmon photographs on social media platforms to inform anglers visually of individual fish being caught.

A Wild Salmon Is A Unique Creature

How can you effectively take some 'city hatched' statistical graph and effectively apply it to something as magically wonderful as the mind set of a totally independent migratory creature that ultimately decides itself exactly when it is going to appear home in its native river. We don't necessarily always see the physical presence of salmon in our rivers to know that there's a high probability they are there. Nor should we be relying on a statistical digit to give us the faith needed to pursue them. Good old natural anticipation is a key component that makes up the magic and draw of Scottish salmon fishing.